Read the arrest of the case C-813/24
On Thursday, October 22, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) issued its judgment in Case C-813/24 (Smartflats), which addressed the assessment of the conformity of the Brussels tourist accommodation regime (ordinance of May 8, 2014) with the European Union Services Directive in response to preliminary questions.
What lessons can we learn from this?
The CJEU :
- upholds the opinion of its Advocate General regarding the illegality of the Brussels regime under European law, particularly with respect to the certificate of compliance with urban planning regulations under Article 13 of the Services Directive (Authorization Procedures) (§ 114–116)
- confirms and expands upon the Advocate General’s analysis, while ultimately leaving it to the referring court, the Brussels Court of Appeal (§ 79), to assess the necessity and proportionality of the Brussels regime on the basis of:
- “a study or any other objective analysis supporting the conclusion that the activity consisting in the provision of tourist accommodation has a significant effect on the supply of housing units in the Brussels-Capital Region and/or on the rent levels for those housing units may constitute a strong indication of such tensions” (§93)
- “the geographical scope of the obligation in question, that is to say, whether it applies uniformly in the Brussels-Capital Region or whether it applies with limited geographical scope, concerning only certain municipalities or certain areas of those municipalities, which are experiencing tensions on the market for housing units following an increase in the activity consisting in the provision of tourist accommodation” (§ 94)
- clearly rules out such an authorization requirement regarding the operator’s primary residence (§ 95)
- further specifies, in conclusion, that a condition of a system that does not comply with the Services Directive “requires the inapplicability of that condition only, provided that it can be detached from the rest of that prior authorisation regime” (§124)
STR-Belgium will follow developments in the case before the Brussels Court of Appeals with interest and stands ready to work with the Brussels Government to build a competitive, innovative, and sustainable tourist lodging market that complies with European law, particularly the Services Directive, and, at a later date, if applicable, the Affordable Housing Act (AHA).

